Deerhurst vs Hidden Valley Resort: Which Resort is Better?
Guide To Ontario contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase using one of the links below, I may receive compensation at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products and services that I use and trust. Thank you for your support! Please read the Privacy Policy for more information.
Planning a getaway to Muskoka and can’t decide which resort to stay at? Deerhurst vs Hidden Valley Resort? That is the ultimate question.
These two classic destinations offer unique experiences for travellers, but they come with their own strengths and weaknesses. Having grown up in Huntsville and gone to both resorts many times, I’ve compiled this comparison to help you decide which one suits your travel style best.
Planning Your Trip? Use My Favourite Resources Below!
- Accommodations – I always use and recommend Booking.com
- Car Rental – I recommend DiscoverCars
- eSIM – I recommend Airalo
- Booking a Tour – I recommend GetYourGuide
- Custom Itinerary – I will create a personalized itinerary for your dream trip!
Location
The resorts are basically neighbours. Hidden Valley is 1 extra minute down the road from Deerhurst, about 10 minutes drive out of Huntsville on Highway 60.
Deerhurst Resort
Deerhurst Resort sits on the shores of Peninsula Lake with a long driveway through its Deerhurst Highlands Golf Course. It’s a sprawling property with several buildings, so while you’ll enjoy the scenic surroundings, you may need to walk 3-10 minutes (or rely on the shuttle) to reach amenities like the pool or restaurants from your room.
Hidden Valley Resort
Hidden Valley is also situated on Peninsula Lake, just east of Huntsville. This resort is smaller and feels more secluded, nestled in nature. Being directly adjacent to the Hidden Valley Ski Hill, it is the most convenient spot for a skiing vacation in the winter.
Price: Deerhurst vs Hidden Vally
Both resorts are priced in the mid-to-upper range, but the value differs:
Deerhurst Resort
While its iconic status and included activities may justify the cost for families, the outdated furnishings and inconsistent housekeeping and front desk service leave some guests feeling shortchanged.
Hidden Valley Resort
The rustic charm and slightly lower price point make it appealing for couples or travellers seeking a quieter atmosphere. However, issues with upkeep may detract from the overall value as well.
Activities and Amenities
I’m going to get right to the point: Deerhurst relies on an abundance of activities to draw guests, and Hidden Valley relies on the ski hill to draw guests. But let’s get into the nuance.
Here’s a breakdown of what each resort provides:
| Activity/Amenity | Deerhurst Resort | Hidden Valley Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Indoor Activities | Indoor Pool, Treehouse Playspace, Fitness Centre, Arcade, Eclipse Art Gallery, HD Golf & Multi-Sport Simulator, Indoor Rock Wall, Escape Cabins | Indoor Pool, Hot Tub, Sauna, Ping Pong/Table Tennis |
| Outdoor Pools | 3 pools (summer only) | 1 pool (summer only) |
| Water Activities | Canoes, Kayaks, SUPs, Jetski Rentals, Cable Park Wakeboarding & Tubing | Canoes, Kayaks, SUPs |
| Land Activities | Golf, Disc Golf, Foot Golf, Mountain Biking, Hiking Trails, Basketball, Tennis, Pickleball, Lawn Games | Basketball, Tennis, Beach Volleyball, Sun Chairs. |
| Beach Access | Private Beach | Private Beach |
| Winter Activities | Snowshoeing, Cross-Country Skiing, Ice-Skating (lit at night), Kick Sleds, Fat Biking, Snowmobiling, Skiing at Muskoka Ski Club (next door) | Skiing at Muskoka Ski Club (walking distance), Ice Skating on the lake, Snowshoeing, Snowmobiling |
| Special Activities | Paintball, Fishing Charters, True North Helicopter Tours, Yamaha Boat Tours, Yamaha ATV Riding Adventures, Treetop Trekking | Fishing, Golfing (at Deerhurst Highlands) |
| Spas | Packages, Massages, Mani/Pedi, Couples, Body wraps, Facials, Men’s treatments | Massages, Facials, Body wraps, Couples |
Key Points to Consider when Comparing Deerhurst vs Hidden Valley Resort
- Variety: Deerhurst offers significantly more variety of activities. However, many of these activities are provided by partner companies and come at an additional cost and could be booked separately.
- Family-Friendliness: Deerhurst’s indoor treehouse, arcade, and kids’ activities make it more appealing for families with young children.
- Skiing & Golfing: Both resorts are well-suited for ski and golf enthusiasts, with Hidden Valley next to the ski hills, and Deerhurst next to the golf courses.
- Relaxation: Hidden Valley’s private beach and smaller scale create a more tranquil atmosphere.
With its extensive list of activities, Deerhurst Resort is ideal for those seeking variety and adventure, though costs can add up. If you’re after a simpler, more serene getaway, Hidden Valley Resort might be your best bet.
Food & Restaurants
Both resorts are about 10 minutes away from the town of Huntsville, where there are many great food options. But, if you’re looking to stay in for food, you must consider your options as both resorts, as they differ drastically.
Deerhurst Resort
Deerhurst has several dining options with glowing reviews. However, these restaurants are not exclusive to guests, so I recommend making reservations. It’s worth noting that the resort is a cashless property, so plan accordingly.
Here’s an overview of their restaurants:
- Eclipse Restaurant & Terrace – Open daily from 8 am to 11 am for breakfast, with buffet options on weekends. Dinner reservations are recommended.
- Maple Pub & Patio – Serving lunch and dinner, this casual eatery is open Sunday through Thursday from 11:30 am to 4 pm, and Friday and Saturday from 11:30 am to 9 pm. It offers a relaxed atmosphere with scenic views.
- Compass Grill & Lounge – Ideal for casual bites, dinner, and bar service, it’s open daily from 4 pm to 11 pm. Live music is featured on Saturdays from 7 pm to 9 pm, with bar service until midnight.
- The Antler Steakhouse – For upscale dining in a rustic log house setting, this steakhouse operates Thursday to Saturday from 5:30 pm to 8 pm. Dinner reservations are required.
- Row & Roast Coffee Co. – Offering local coffee and snacks, it’s open Saturday from 7 am to 3 pm and Sunday from 7 am to 12 pm.
Hidden Valley Resort
Hidden Valley Resort’s in-house restaurant, The Birches, focuses on fresh, locally sourced ingredients to deliver an authentic Muskoka dining experience.
The menu features classic favourites with a modern twist, ensuring something for everyone. For those seeking a drink, the resort also has a bar lounge that offers a relaxed atmosphere, perfect for unwinding after a day of activities.
It is open for breakfast from 7:00 AM to 10:00 AM and dinner from 5:00 PM to 9:00 PM, but some reviews have mentioned that the kitchen doesn’t always stick to these times.
FAQs
When deciding between Deerhurst Resort or Hidden Valley Resort, there are a lot of factors to consider. Here are my answers to some commonly asked questions.
Deerhurst vs Hidden Valley: Which resort is better for families with kids?
Deerhurst Resort offers a wide range of kid-friendly amenities like an indoor treehouse play space, arcade, and family activities such as escape rooms and rock climbing. Hidden Valley Resort provides fewer activities specifically for kids, but still has classics like canoes, kayaks, and a beach on the lake.
Which resort is better for winter activities?
Both resorts are excellent for winter fun. Deerhurst has a broader range of activities (according to their website), but the truth is, you can easily book and rent the same activities at both resorts. Deerhurst can simply arrange it for you. Hidden Valley, on the other hand, is right on the ski hill, making it a great choice for ski enthusiasts.
Which resort offers better dining options?
Deerhurst Resort has a wider variety of dining experiences, from casual pub fare to fine dining at The Antler Steakhouse. Hidden Valley Resort’s main dining option, The Birches, is top-notch and focuses on locally sourced, seasonal ingredients and offers a cozier, more intimate atmosphere. However, it’s only open for breakfast and dinner.
Which resort provides more value for the price?
Deerhurst offers a larger variety of amenities and activities, but many come at an additional cost and are operated by third-party providers. Hidden Valley, while more modest in its offerings, provides a more peaceful, inclusive experience that can feel like better value for those seeking relaxation over activity-packed days.
What is there to do in Huntsville?
There is a ton of outdoor activities to explore in and around my hometown, or you can enjoy the historic charm of our downtown. Check out my full guide to things to do in Huntsville, my favourite breakfast spots in town, or all the winter activities to try in Muskoka for more inspiration.
The Verdict: Deerhurst vs Hidden Valley Resort
If you’re seeking a family-friendly resort packed with activities and don’t mind navigating a large property, Deerhurst Resort is a solid choice—just prepare for some minor inconveniences with service and layout.
For a quieter, nature-focused retreat with fewer included activities, Hidden Valley Resort delivers a cozy Muskoka vibe at a slightly lower cost. Confirm room details directly to avoid booking mishaps.
No matter where you stay, at Deerhurst, Hidden Valley, or somewhere else near Huntsville, you will get to enjoy Muskoka’s stunning beauty and year-round outdoor adventures. I hope you enjoy visiting my neck of the woods!
